Most American Main Streets between roughly 1880 and 1950 share a common building type: narrow, multi-story commercial structures built directly to the sidewalk, with shops below and offices or apartments above. Identifying which architectural style a given building wears is a matter of reading two zones separately — the ornamental upper façade and the ground-floor storefront, which often changed with successive generations of tenants. The two styles that can be identified most reliably from the street are the Italianate, dominant in the later nineteenth century, and the Neoclassical, which persisted into the 1930s.
The Main Street Commercial Building Type
What unites these buildings is not a single style but a shared template. A Main Street commercial building is pedestrian-oriented, sits at the zero lot line with its façade flush to the sidewalk, and stacks retail space on the ground floor beneath upper stories of office or residential use. That template was remarkably stable across decades, which is why the same basic form can carry very different ornament depending on when it was built.
Historic photographs illustrate how the two zones age differently. A surviving 1870s building in Galena, Illinois, originally had two identical storefronts and upper façades; one storefront still contains its original cast-iron columns and wooden millwork, while a second-generation replacement installed around 1910 uses a prism glass transom and metal window framing instead. The upper stories, in other words, often preserve the building's original style while the storefront records its later commercial history — a point emphasized in Washington's Main Street preservation materials.
Even buildings that never had a typical storefront can display the era's signature detailing. The Cattle Bank Building in Champaign, Illinois, built in 1857, lacks the standard shopfront, but its form and upper-story window hoods and cornice are described by Main Street preservation writers as typical of such buildings throughout the later half of the nineteenth century.
Main Street Commercial Architectural Style Identification Guide
The table below is a working identification tool. To use it, look first at the building's top edge and upper windows, then at the storefront, and match what you see against the two style profiles. The comparison in this guide focuses on Italianate and Neoclassical styles, though Craftsman, Art Deco, and Art Moderne commercial buildings are also found on Main Streets.
| Style | Typical Period | Key Upper-Façade Features | Common Storefront Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Italianate | 1840–1880; declined soon after the Civil War, so Main Street examples fall in the earlier part of the 1880–1950 era | Low-pitched roof with projecting eaves supported by brackets; a strong, projecting cornice defining the top of the building; window hoods and ornamented upper windows; tall first-floor windows and arches | Storefronts of the later nineteenth century typically used cast-iron columns and wooden millwork; cornices could be brick, wood, or sheet metal rather than stone |
| Neoclassical | Prevailed into the 1930s, aligning with the later part of the Main Street era | Classical ornament applied with meticulous precision and at massive scale — columned porticoes, pilasters, keystones, pedimented openings, and dentils along the cornice; symmetry and monumental formality | Storefronts integrate classical elements with large display windows and grand entrances, maintaining an overall sense of formality and permanence |
How to read the Italianate clues
Italianate architecture took Italian farmhouses as its inspiration and began in Great Britain before spreading widely, as the U.S. General Services Administration's survey of its own historic buildings explains. Its hallmark from the street is the roofline: a low-pitched roof with wide, projecting eaves held up by visible brackets, finished with a strong projecting cornice. Because the roof itself is usually not visible from the sidewalk, that cornice does the work of terminating the building. Tall first-floor windows, arched openings, and — in the Italian Villa subtype — square towers complete the picture.
On a Main Street, Italianate means the later nineteenth century. The style declined in popularity soon after the Civil War, so a bracketed, heavy-corniced commercial block most likely predates the 1880s storefront boom, and its ground floor has probably been reworked several times since. When evaluating an Italianate building, the original cast-iron storefront posts or wooden millwork, if they survive beneath later signage, are as significant as the upper façade.
How to read the Neoclassical clues
Neoclassicism is classical ornament with a different temperament. The Wabash Valley architectural guide distinguishes it sharply from the earlier Greek Revival: where Greek Revival interpreted classical details casually and at modest scale, Neoclassical buildings are meticulously detailed and often massive. The style prevailed into the 1930s and appeared most notably in large public and commercial buildings and in skyscrapers — meaning a Main Street bank, theater, or substantial mercantile block with a formal colonnade likely dates from the first third of the twentieth century.
The checklist is concrete: a columned portico, pilasters flanking the bays, keystones above openings, pediments, and dentils running along the cornice. A sophisticated example of the mode is the Albert A. Wells Memorial Library, a limestone building dominated by a recessed entry fronted by four massive free-standing Ionic columns — the same vocabulary, at civic scale, that a Neoclassical commercial building carries in compressed form.
Why Style Identification Matters for Preservation
Dating a building by its style is more than trivia. Architectural style is a primary line of evidence in evaluating a property's historical significance, the step that determines whether a building may qualify for recognition in programs such as the National Register of Historic Places. A well-preserved Italianate upper façade documents the earliest phase of a downtown's commercial development; a Neoclassical storefront records the early-twentieth-century era of civic ambition and institutional banking. Layers matter too: that Galena building's 1910 storefront is not a violation of its 1870s style but a legible record of continuous commercial use, and preservation evaluations generally weigh such evolution rather than erasing it.
The identification process also protects against mislabeling. Mistaking a Neoclassical cornice for Greek Revival, or a 1910 remodel for original fabric, can misdate a building and weaken its case for designation. Reading the two zones — upper façade and storefront — as separate documents in the same wall is the discipline that makes the classification reliable.
Preserving Main Street's Architectural Heritage
Identifying a building's architectural style is a foundational step for its historical evaluation and inclusion in preservation programs. The decision it supports is concrete: before a property can be argued significant — to a local landmarks commission, a state historic preservation office, or a National Register nomination — someone must establish what it is and when it was built, and the style provides that evidence.
The measurable indicator is simple and checkable: successful identification of architectural elements and styles in local Main Street buildings. Walk your own downtown with the table above, separate the cornice and window hoods from the storefront glass, and you have begun the same documentary work that formal preservation review builds upon.
Sources
- DAHP
- Wabashvalleytrust
- Explore by architectural style — U.S. General Services Administration





